Everything Toastie menu with up-to-date-prices

Everything Toastie Menu

September 7, 2026
by
1 min read

Everything Toastie is an independent café at 63 Carr Lane in Hull city centre. Open daily for brunch, lunch and afternoon visits, it turns the familiar toasted sandwich into a focused menu served in a small, cosy space opposite Primark.

Each toastie starts with fresh sourdough and a generous filling. Combinations include halloumi with rose harissa and jalapeño honey, jerk spiced chicken with mozzarella and cheddar, and seasoned beef with peppers, onions and melted cheese.

A house dipping sauce built around West African spices accompanies the sandwiches, with soup available as an alternative. Rotating specials keep the concise menu changing, while vegetarian fillings provide useful contrast to the beef and chicken choices.

Coffee, smoothies and other café drinks make the space suitable for a shorter stop as well as a full lunch. The friendly counter service, informal seating and portable format give Everything Toastie the flexibility of a takeaway without losing its relaxed café atmosphere.

Address: 63 Carr Lane, Kingston upon Hull HU1 3RQ, England

Everything Toastie Menu

Toasties

Every toastie comes with a side of salad. Extra £1 for any additional filling. For allergens please ask staff.

Pepperoni pizza
£8.99

Pepperoni, tomato sauce, cheddar, mozzarella, Sourdough bread

Yes chef
£8.99

Pulled pork, house sauce, cheddar, mozzarella, Sourdough bread

Sweet button (V)
£8.99

Mushrooms with onions and a raspberry jam, cheddar, mozzarella, Sourdough bread

House toastie
£8.99
House sauce (V)
£8.99

House sauce (A tomato based sauce with herbs and seasoning), cheddar, mozzarella, Sourdough bread

Tuna melt
£8.99

Tuna, mayonnaise, spring onion and red onion, cheddar, mozzarella, Sourdough bread

Cheesy Esther mushrooms (V)
£8.99

Refried baked beans with onion, garlic, chilli and seasoning, cheddar, mozzarella, Sourdough bread

Hands down
£8.99

Cured ham (formed), Cheddar, mozzarella, Sourdough bread

Classic grilled cheese (V)
£8.99

Four cheese: Cheddar, mozzarella, gouda and emmental, Sourdough bread

Salt bae
£8.99

Bacon, cheddar, mozzarella, Sourdough bread

Cheese and tomatoes (V)
£8.99

Sundried tomatoes, pesto, cheddar, mozzarella, Sourdough bread

Cheese and onion (V)
£8.99

Onion, Cheddar, mozzarella, gouda and emmental, Sourdough bread

Sweet toasties
£4.99

Marshmallow, Nutella or Biscoff, Sourdough bread

Loaded Fries

Melt down
£4.49

Chicken, pepperoni, mozzarella, and BBQ sauce

Pepperoni pizza
£4.49

Pepperoni, tomato sauce, cheddar, mozzarella

Asian fusion (V)
£4.49

Kimchi and ET creation sauce, cheddar, mozzarella

Jacket Potatoes

Fillings: Cheese, Ether Beans, Bacon, Tuna mayo with onions, Chicken mayo, Mushrooms, House sauce. Extra £1 for any additional filling.

Plain with butter
£5.49
1 Filling
£7.99
2 Fillings
£8.99

Extras

Desserts – please visit the counter!

Fries
£1.99