Rustlings Pantry is a friendly daytime cafe and deli at 5 Rustlings Road in Sheffield, directly opposite Endcliffe Park. Run by two brothers, the compact neighbourhood venue offers eat-in and outdoor tables alongside takeaway and delivery.
Breakfast covers both full plates and hot sandwiches, with bacon, egg, sausage, beans, mushrooms, tomato, hash browns and toast available in familiar combinations. Tea and coffee make it a practical stop before a walk or an unhurried weekend brunch.
The deli side brings more distinctive choices, including Reuben, Cuban and muffaletta sandwiches. The muffaletta layers mortadella, salami, ham, provolone and olive tapenade on pressed focaccia, while a grilled cheese combines cheddar, Swiss cheese and mozzarella on sourdough.
Jacket potatoes, burgers, homemade chips, soup, cakes and snacks round out the selection, with roast meat sandwiches prepared as a weekly special. Guests with allergies should contact the cafe directly before ordering, particularly because the menu spans breads, dairy, meats and other common allergens.
Address: 5 Rustlings Road, Sheffield S11 7AA, England
Rustlings Pantry Menu
Most Popular Products
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Cheddar, swiss and mozzarella served on grilled sourdough
Muffaletta Sandwich
Mortadella, salami, ham, provolone cheese, olive tapenade served on pressed focaccia
Chilli and Cheese Jacket Potato
Served with butter
Chilli and Cheese
Sausage Sandwich
English Breakfast
Bacon, egg, sausage, beans, tomatoes, mushrooms, hash brown, white or granary toast & butter served with coffee/tea
Best Sandwich
Bacon, egg, sausage and tomato
Bacon and Sausage Sandwich
Salads
Ceaser Salad
Romaine lettuce, croutons, caesar dressing, grilled chicken or grilled halloumi, shaved parmesan
Greek Salad
Tomatoes, cucumber, red onion, bell peppers, feta cheese, olives and greek dressing
NY House Chopped Salad
Lettuce, pepperoni, salami, tomato, red onion, swiss cheese, dill pickles and house dressing
Breakfast
English Breakfast
Bacon, egg, sausage, beans, tomatoes, mushrooms, hash brown, white or granary toast & butter served with coffee/tea
Veg/Vegan Breakfast
Vegan bacon, egg or scrambled tofu, vegan sausage, beans, tomatoes, mushrooms, hash browns, white or granary toast & butter served with coffee/tea
Breakfast Specials
GFO available
Breakfast Burrito
Bacon, sausage, scrambled egg, cheddar cheese, mixed peppers, onions and hash brown served in a tortilla wrap
Veg/Vegan Breakfast Burrito
Vegan bacon, vegan sausage, scrambled egg or tofu, vegan cheese and hash brown served in a tortilla wrap
House Granola
Served with greek yogurt, fruit compote and fresh fruit
Chorizo Hash
Grilled chorizo, skin on potatoes, fried egg, spinach, garlic aioli, chillis and spring onions
Eggs on Toast
Fried, scrambled or poached eggs served on sourdough
Artisan Toast
Sourdough bread served with butter, Nutella or jam
Sandwiches
Served on breadcake – VGO/GFO on all
Bacon Sandwich
Sausage Sandwich
Bacon and Sausage Sandwich
Best Sandwich
Bacon, egg, sausage and tomato
Deli Sandwiches
GFO available
Reuben Sandwich
Pastrami, swiss cheese, sauerkraut, russian dressing, sliced dill pickles served on pressed sourdough
Cuban Sandwich
Sliced roast pork, ham, swiss cheese, sliced dill pickles, yellow mustard served on pressed ciabatta
Muffaletta Sandwich
Mortadella, salami, ham, provolone cheese, olive tapenade served on pressed focaccia
Italian Sandwich
Sliced pepperoni, salami, ham, provolone cheese, shredded lettuce, tomato, red onion, italian vinaigrette served on ciabatta
Chicken and Chorizo Sandwich
Grilled chicken, chorizo, buffalo mozzarella and pesto served on pressed focaccia
Veggie Sandwich
Buffalo mozzarella, beef tomatoes, pesto and spinach served on pressed focaccia
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Cheddar, swiss and mozzarella served on grilled sourdough
The Humble Spud
Hand Cut Chips
Salt and Pepper Chips
Poutine
Blue Cheese and Buffalo Sauce
Chilli and Cheese
Plain Jacket Potato
Served with butter
Cheese Jacket Potato
Served with butter
Beans Jacket Potato
Served with butter
Cheese and Beans Jacket Potato
Served with butter
Chilli Jacket Potato
Served with butter
Chilli and Cheese Jacket Potato
Served with butter
Coleslaw Jacket Potato
Served with butter
Kids Menu
Kids English Breakfast
Kids Sausage, Chips and Beans
Kids Burger, Chips and Beans
Kids Penne Pasta
Served with marinara or pesto sauce and garlic bread
From Happy Menu members
Reviews from locals: every member has confirmed a UK mobile.
Been to Rustlings Pantry? Be one of the first to rate it.
+ Log your visitNearby
Within 3 miles of Rustlings Pantry
- British T The Psalter 0.2 mi ·£ British · Pub
- Indian M Mowgli Street Food Sheffield 0.3 mi Indian · Street Food
- British L Lounge 418 0.6 mi ·£ British · Fusion
- British N Nether Edge Cafe 0.7 mi ·£ British · Breakfast & Brunch
- Italian B Borgo 0.7 mi ·£ Italian
- British T The Prince of Wales Sheffield 0.7 mi ·£ British · Pub
More British nearby
Within 6 miles
- British T Thyme Café 0.8 mi ·£ British · European
- British T The Tramshed Sheffield 1.4 mi ·£ British · Pub
- British T The Howard Sheffield 1.9 mi ·£ British · Pub
- British L Loxley Sports Bar & Grill 2.4 mi ·£ British · Grill
- British T The Water Tower 2.9 mi ·£ British · Pub
- British D Devonshire Arms Sheffield 3.5 mi ·£ British · Pub