The Devil's Advocate menu with up-to-date-prices

The Devil’s Advocate Menu

September 6, 2026
by
1 min read

The Devil’s Advocate is a bar and restaurant hidden in a nineteenth century pump house on Advocate’s Close. Stone walls, timber and soft amber light give the historic Old Town building a warm, atmospheric interior just off the Royal Mile. A restaurant, mezzanine and covered terrace provide different settings for lunch, dinner, drinks and larger gatherings.

The food celebrates seasonal Scottish produce through bold but comforting plates. Fresh seafood and 32 day dry aged Scotch steaks sit alongside handmade pasta, snacks and dishes intended for sharing. Menus change as ingredients move through the year, allowing the kitchen to retain a clear Scottish identity without being limited to a fixed collection of classics.

Lunch offers a relaxed way into the restaurant, while dinner supports a longer progression through starters, substantial mains and desserts. Groups can use tailored menus and shared dining options in the mezzanine or terrace spaces. The historic building involves stairs, an important practical detail for guests planning a visit.

Whisky is the soul of the bar, with more than 300 Scottish and international bottles and flights designed to compare regions, styles and cask finishes. Inventive cocktails, wine, craft beer and a strong range of low and no alcohol drinks provide alternatives. The Devil’s Advocate brings food, spirits and Edinburgh heritage together without turning any one of them into a backdrop.

Address: 9 Advocate’s Close, Edinburgh EH1 1ND, United Kingdom

For restaurant owners Own this restaurant? Turn this menu into direct orders. Claim this page, keep your menu current and let customers order dine in or pickup with no Happy Menu percentage commission.
Claim this menu

Devil's Advocate Menu

For the Table

Artisan sourdough, butter
£4
Crispy pork belly bites, miso rum dip
£6
Mixed olive bowl
£5

Starters

Seasonal soup of the day
£8.50

artisan sourdough, butter

Haggis bon-bons
£9.75

charred pineapple salsa, rocket & apple salad, miso mayo

Grilled Scottish mackerel
£10.50

green fish velouté, radish, shredded cabbage, cumin oil, pea shoots

Game dumplings
£11

Inverloch goats cheddar, fresh fig, lollo rosso, pickled fennel salad & elderflower dressing

Smoked beetroot tartare
£8.50

raspberry balsamic reduction, crispy capers, lambs leaf lettuce, feta

Sharing Boards

Charcuterie
£32

Selection of Scottish charcuterie meats, Isle of Mull cheddar, Strathdon blue, Inverloch goats cheddar, Arran oaties, fruit, cornichons, pickled red onion, mixed olives, rum honey, sweetcorn salsa, sourdough

Smoked Fish
£32

Hot and cold smoked salmon, tartare sauce, Arbroath smokie pate, mixed olives, Arran oaties, lemon, pickled red onion, cornichons, rum honey, sweetcorn salsa, sourdough

Mains

Aberdeen Angus burger
£19.50

Isle of Mull Cheddar, onion & bacon relish, house mayo, rocket, gherkins, house chips

Fish & chips
£19.50

tempura battered Scottish haddock, tartare, pickled onion, rocket, lemon, house chips

Smoked aubergine & sweetcorn keftedes
£18.50

heritage tomatoes, sherry vinegar dressing, fresh basil, oregano & haricot bean mash, straw onions

Rum & miso glazed pork belly
£24

carrot & cucumber picked slaw, tenderstem broccoli, polenta chips

32 Day Dry-Aged Scotch Steaks

Roasted cherry tomatoes, house chips, rocket salad. A choice of smoked whisky peppercorn sauce or sweetcorn salsa.

Top Sirloin
£36.50
Flat iron
£32

Sides

House chips
£5.50 / add confit garlic + £1 / add miso mayo, straw onions + £2
House salad
£6

gooseberry vinegarette

Carrot, cucumber & fennel picked slaw
£5
Seared tenderstem broccoli
£6.50

raspberry balsamic reduction

Dinner Mains

Scottish Lamb Rump
£34

sweet mustard & shallot puree, charred aubergine, wilted sorrel, wild mint & watermelon coulis

Char grilled pork chop
£23

charred courgette, romanesco, leek puree, sweetcorn salsa, crispy kale

Smoked aubergine & sweetcorn keftedes
£18.50

heritage tomatoes, sherry vinegar dressing, fresh basil, oregano & haricot bean mash, straw onions

Pan seared Scottish hake
£28

lemon & better black pepper broth, new potatoes, pak choi, sea herbs, seaweed, sweet cicely oil